Let's All Be Wyverns?
Aug. 1st, 2008 06:13 am.....Last night was our non-regularly scheduled Wyvern meeting in the Barony of Dragon's Laire. The Order of the Wyvern is a Baronial level Service Polling Order. Now, for the sake of this headache producing mini-rant, we'll leave the whole topic of a Baronial Level Service POLLING order alone for the moment as it is an entirely different debate.
.....I think I may be alone in this, but I find Wyvern meetings to be extremely painful for some reason, and I can't precisely put my finger on why. One would think that I would find going to Pelican meetings to be more painful, but I don't. Don't misunderstand me, Pelican meetings can be extremely frustrating, but in an entirely different way.
.....Whenever we get together at a Wyvern's meeting we go through a list of people who are on our 'watch' list, and we debate the merits of their being recommended to Their Excellencies as additional members to the Order. Generally, those merits include a certain number of years of service to the Barony in a couple of different disciplines. The Order looks at a candidates ability to autocrat an event or take on a Baronial office.
.....Character is not SUPPOSED to be an issue as far as this award is concerned. This is supposed to be confined to an amount of service given to the Barony.
.....I think that the part I seem to have the most problem with is the arbitrariness of the selection process. We have a more or less stated set of criteria, but that criteria seems to shift depending on a.) the candidate, b.) the people present performing in the debate, and c.) the mood of the group at any given meeting.
.....Of course one can come back and say that the exact same thing happens at the Kingdom Level with the Polling Orders, especially with the Pelicans as the 'criteria' for Pelican service is so nebulous. But even with the frustrations surrounding that Kingdom process, every time I compare the two I find myself siding with the Kingdom process as being more complete and less arbitrary.
.....I suppose that part of my problem is the fact that I keep mentally doing this comparison, which is probably very unfair. We're talking a second level Baronial service award where strictly service is viewed and character is not a part of the equation versus a Kingdom level peerage award where the process is viewed so much more critically and character is a definitive part of the debate.
.....I suppose that there is also another aspect to this. If Their Excellencies actually received written recommendations for awards from the Baronial populace, would they really need a council to make recommendations to them? Their Excellencies are constantly asking, begging, pleading for people to submit letters that recommend awards to various members of the populace, and they receive very few. They can probably count on one hand the number of letters and e-mails that they've received during the past year recommending people. A Polling Order at least enhances the chances that at least a few people are going to be promoted for award.
.....Maybe we, as a group, need to concentrate on recognizing our own members more. Hmmm, as I start winding up this little mini-rant, I'm starting to wonder if maybe I ought to be looking into the mirror rather than railing against a process. There are things I could do on a personal level to recognize people for the efforts they've done on behalf of the Barony. People appreciate being recognized for the good things they've done, and it makes them want to do more.
.....O.K., I'm done whining on this at the moment and will give it more thought. See if I can come to some sort of inner resolution, or at least more of a focus on what troubles me so much about the Wyverns, before I start whining again about it in my Journal.
.....Aaron / Arontius.
.....I think I may be alone in this, but I find Wyvern meetings to be extremely painful for some reason, and I can't precisely put my finger on why. One would think that I would find going to Pelican meetings to be more painful, but I don't. Don't misunderstand me, Pelican meetings can be extremely frustrating, but in an entirely different way.
.....Whenever we get together at a Wyvern's meeting we go through a list of people who are on our 'watch' list, and we debate the merits of their being recommended to Their Excellencies as additional members to the Order. Generally, those merits include a certain number of years of service to the Barony in a couple of different disciplines. The Order looks at a candidates ability to autocrat an event or take on a Baronial office.
.....Character is not SUPPOSED to be an issue as far as this award is concerned. This is supposed to be confined to an amount of service given to the Barony.
.....I think that the part I seem to have the most problem with is the arbitrariness of the selection process. We have a more or less stated set of criteria, but that criteria seems to shift depending on a.) the candidate, b.) the people present performing in the debate, and c.) the mood of the group at any given meeting.
.....Of course one can come back and say that the exact same thing happens at the Kingdom Level with the Polling Orders, especially with the Pelicans as the 'criteria' for Pelican service is so nebulous. But even with the frustrations surrounding that Kingdom process, every time I compare the two I find myself siding with the Kingdom process as being more complete and less arbitrary.
.....I suppose that part of my problem is the fact that I keep mentally doing this comparison, which is probably very unfair. We're talking a second level Baronial service award where strictly service is viewed and character is not a part of the equation versus a Kingdom level peerage award where the process is viewed so much more critically and character is a definitive part of the debate.
.....I suppose that there is also another aspect to this. If Their Excellencies actually received written recommendations for awards from the Baronial populace, would they really need a council to make recommendations to them? Their Excellencies are constantly asking, begging, pleading for people to submit letters that recommend awards to various members of the populace, and they receive very few. They can probably count on one hand the number of letters and e-mails that they've received during the past year recommending people. A Polling Order at least enhances the chances that at least a few people are going to be promoted for award.
.....Maybe we, as a group, need to concentrate on recognizing our own members more. Hmmm, as I start winding up this little mini-rant, I'm starting to wonder if maybe I ought to be looking into the mirror rather than railing against a process. There are things I could do on a personal level to recognize people for the efforts they've done on behalf of the Barony. People appreciate being recognized for the good things they've done, and it makes them want to do more.
.....O.K., I'm done whining on this at the moment and will give it more thought. See if I can come to some sort of inner resolution, or at least more of a focus on what troubles me so much about the Wyverns, before I start whining again about it in my Journal.
.....Aaron / Arontius.